Cost matters when you're picking siding, and so does the climate it has to live in, the HOA rules you have to work within, and how long you plan to stay in the house. Here are the four materials we install, with an honest note on where each one fits and where we'd steer you somewhere cheaper instead.
Most common Vinyl Siding
Lifespan 20-30 yrs · Cost $$
Vinyl is the most-installed siding in the country for good reason: it's affordable, it never needs repainting, and it comes in dozens of colors and profiles now, including the modern board-and-batten and shake looks that used to require wood. The newer thick-grade vinyl handles Colorado UV and temperature swings better than the cheap stuff did ten years ago. Hail can crack it, but individual panels are easy to swap out.
We'd point you here for most Front Range homes, for any HOA that allows vinyl, and for owners who don't want repainting on the maintenance list.
Best value Engineered Wood (LP SmartSide)
Lifespan 30-50 yrs · Cost $$
Engineered wood gives you the look of real wood without most of its problems, because it's factory-primed, dimensionally stable, and treated against rot and insects. It's lighter than fiber cement, which means faster installs and lower labor cost, and we're seeing it on more and more mountain-style and craftsman-style new builds across the Front Range.
We'd point you here if you want the wood aesthetic without cedar's maintenance, or if you're chasing fiber-cement looks at a vinyl-adjacent price.
Premium Fiber Cement (HardiePlank)
Lifespan 40-50 yrs · Cost $$$
If you've seen a high-end remodel in Colorado in the last decade, there's a good chance it's wearing HardiePlank. It looks like real wood from the curb, holds paint for 10 to 15 years between repaints, and stays dimensionally stable through both fire and Front Range temperature swings. It's heavier and more labor to install than vinyl, so the structural detail under it matters, but for a house you plan to keep more than ten years, this is the material that pays you back.
We'd point you here for luxury and modern homes, for neighborhoods where appearance carries weight, and for anyone replacing failing cedar.
Heritage Real Cedar Shake & Shingle
Lifespan 20-30 yrs · Cost $$$
Real cedar is beautiful, but Colorado is harder on it than almost any other climate, because UV dries it out, hail bruises it, and most insurance carriers have started excluding or capping cedar replacement coverage. We'll install it when an HOA requires it, but in almost every other case we'll walk you through the synthetic alternatives first, since they look nearly identical from the curb and last decades longer.
We'd only point you here for historic or HOA-restricted homes where the original cedar is non-negotiable.
Not sure which is right for your house? Have us out for a free consultation and we'll look at what's there, what's behind the wall, your structure, and your HOA rules. We don't get paid more for the expensive one. If you'd rather research first, our Colorado Siding Planning Guide is a 25-minute read for the deep-dive version.